Судлаачид хөхтөн амьтдын хувьслын явцад усан амьдралын хэв маяг руу шилжихдээ эргэж буцах боломжгүй болдог тодорхой босго байгааг илрүүлжээ.
Бруна М. Фарина, Сёрен Фаурби болон Даниеле Сильвестро нар 5,635 зүйл хөхтөн амьтны мэдээлэлд дүн шинжилгээ хийж, тэднийг усан орчинд дасан зохицсон байдлаар нь дөрвөн ангилалд хуваасан байна. Энэхүү судалгаагаар амьтад усан амьдралд бүрэн дасан зохицохын өмнөх шатанд буюу А1-ээс А2 ангилал руу шилжих үед хувьслын эргэлт буцалтгүй өөрчлөлт гардаг болохыг тогтоожээ. Уг босгыг давсан амьтад дахин хуурай газрын амьдралд бүрэн дасан зохицох чадваргүй болдог аж.
Судалгаанд дурдсанаар, усан орчинд бүрэн дасан зохицсон халим, далайн гахай, орорка зэрэг амьтад физиологи, анатомийн гүнзгий өөрчлөлтөд орсон байдаг. Долло-гийн хуулийн дагуу эдгээр нарийн төвөгтэй биологийн шинж чанаруудыг алдсаны дараа хувьслын явцад тэдгээрийг дахин сэргээх нь маш хүндрэлтэй байдаг байна. Мөн усан амьдралд шилжсэнээр биеийн хэмжээ томрох, дулаан хадгалах болон идэш тэжээлийн онцлог өөрчлөгдөх зэрэг хүчин зүйлүүд нь хуурай газар руу буцахад саад болдог.
Энэхүү үр дүн нь зөвхөн анатомийн өөрчлөлтөөр хязгаарлагдахгүй, харин тухайн амьтны амьдарч буй экологийн орчинтой шууд холбоотой юм. Хуурай газар руу буцах оролдлого хийх нь аль хэдийн хуурай газрын амьдралд төгс дасан зохицсон махчин амьтдын дунд амьд үлдэх сорилттой тулгарна. Ийнхүү Proceedings of the Royal Society B сэтгүүлд нийтлэгдсэн энэхүү судалгаа нь хөхтөн амьтдын усан орчин дахь хувьслын хэв шинжийг статистикийн хүчтэй үндэслэлээр тайлбарлаж байна.
Дэлгэрэнгүйг эх сурвалжаас харах
↓Эх сурвалжийг нээх ↓
A platypus can swim for food, then move efficiently across land. A sea lion can haul itself ashore, though its body is far better built for water. A dolphin never leaves the water at all.
Researchers used those differences as part of a four-step scale for examining what happened as mammal ancestors shifted from terrestrial life toward increasingly aquatic lifestyles.
The results point to a transition that can reverse at its earliest stage. Later, something changes. In a study published in Proceedings of the Royal Society B, researchers found strong statistical support for evolutionary transitions becoming effectively irreversible once mammals acquire sufficiently extensive aquatic adaptations.
Not literally impossible under every conceivable future condition. The authors use irreversibility in an evolutionary sense: after certain adaptations pile up, a return to an earlier state can become extremely unlikely.
The Threshold Appears Before Fully Aquatic Life
Bruna M. Farina, Søren Faurby and Daniele Silvestro assembled data for 5,635 living and recently extinct mammal species, bringing together habitat information, body mass, diet and mammalian evolutionary relationships.
They sorted the species into four categories based on their physical adaptations to water. The A0 category contained mammals without distinct aquatic adaptations. A1 covered animals with aquatic features, such as webbing, that could still move efficiently on land. The platypus and water shrew were among the examples.
More restricted on land, A2 mammals still regularly come ashore. That category specifically included pinnipeds such as seals, sea lions and walruses, along with the sea otter.
A3 was different: mammals that remain entirely in the water. Cetaceans and sirenians fell here, meaning whales, dolphins, manatees and dugongs. Orcas are cetaceans. They therefore sit in this fully aquatic category.
To see how often lineages appeared to move between those states, the researchers tested several evolutionary models. The model with the strongest statistical backing allowed reversals only between A0 and A1.
Mammals with relatively modest aquatic adaptations, in other words, could evolve back toward a fully terrestrial form. Once a lineage crossed into the A2 level, the model backed movement toward greater aquatic specialization but not a return to terrestriality.
The critical threshold therefore fell between A1 and A2, according to the researchers, before an animal necessarily reaches the completely aquatic condition seen in dolphins.
That distinction matters. The study was not a test of whether modern dolphins or orcas might someday grow legs and walk onto land; it examined evolutionary patterns across the mammalian family tree and asked which transition model best accounted for the distribution of aquatic adaptations found across thousands of species.
Aquatic Specialization Changes More Than Limbs
The proposed barrier is not simply about legs disappearing or changing shape.
As mammals adapt strongly to life in water, changes accumulate across locomotion, sensory systems, feeding, reproduction and lung capacity. In cetacean evolution, hind-limb reduction came alongside changes in gene expression. Fully aquatic mammals also show extensive morphological and physiological specialization for their environment.
Those patterns fit with Dollo’s law, the evolutionary principle that once complex biological traits are lost, recreating the same structures through evolution can be exceptionally difficult.
The researchers argue that this buildup of changes helps explain why increasingly aquatic mammal lineages do not simply retrace their route and recover an effective terrestrial body plan. Ecology may make that barrier tougher still.
A mammal attempting a return to land, the study notes, would also meet terrestrial carnivores already equipped with limbs and feeding adaptations suited to hunting and manipulating prey there.
So the obstacles may lie both in the animal’s altered anatomy and in the environment it would have to re-enter.
Moving Into Water Also Favored Bigger Bodies
Another pattern emerged from the analysis: aquatic mammal lineages tended to become larger as their dependence on water increased.
The estimated relative increase in body mass was 4.66 percent per million years for A1 lineages, compared with 12.32 percent for A2 and 11.67 percent for fully aquatic A3 lineages.
Part of that overall tendency, the researchers suggested, may come from the thermal demands of life in water, where heat is lost more readily than in air. Bigger bodies have a lower surface-area-to-volume ratio. They retain heat more efficiently.
Aquatic mammals were also disproportionately associated with more carnivorous diets, whereas herbivory was more strongly associated with terrestrial mammals. The researchers suggested that access to protein-rich food and the metabolic demands of aquatic life may help account for that pattern.
Evolution does not stop when an animal becomes aquatic. Dolphins, orcas and other marine mammals continue to evolve.
Enjoyed this article? Subscribe to our free newsletter for engaging stories, exclusive content, and the latest news.
